“Looking back on my childhood and the way that my parents raised me, I can’t think of anything that was negative,” Erin Bates Pain (who joined the fam on May 2, 1991) told People. “Everything, looking back, is really positive, and we made the best memories.”
While they didn’t have a television “we substituted that for playtime with dad,” she continued. “Or, you know, playing games as a family or making memories. So, I don’t feel like we missed out on anything and, actually, I think we were smarter because of it.”
Which meant that after she married Charles “Chad” Stephen Paine III in 2013, they were eager for a big brood of their own. A blood clotting disorder let to several miscarriages before they were able to welcome Carson in May 2015, Brooklyn in August 2016, Everly in May 2018, Holland in November 2019 and Finley in January 2022. And though she believed they wouldn’t be able to have more children, they went on to grow their family with William in October 2023 and Henry in August 2025. Revealing that Erin had gone into septic shock following Henry’s delivery, Chad wrote on Instagram. “We would so appreciate your prayers for Erin as she continues to recover from some complications.”